Bid protests are a critical part of federal contracting, requiring contracting officers to act quickly and carefully to manage disputes over procurement decisions. This guide provides a clear checklist to navigate these situations effectively, ensuring compliance with federal regulations and maintaining transparency. Key steps include:
- Immediate Actions: Notify stakeholders, halt contract activities, and share relevant documents promptly.
- Documentation: Compile all required records, including solicitation details, evaluation materials, and protest correspondence.
- Organization: Use a systematic approach to organize and store records securely, ensuring easy access and compliance.
- Legal Consultation: Engage legal advisors early to guide decisions and actions during the protest process.
- Post-Protest Steps: Address corrective actions, communicate resolutions, and refine procurement practices.
Government Contacting – FAR Part 33 – Protests, Disputes, and Appeals – Win Federal Contracts
First Steps When a Bid Protest Is Filed
When a bid protest lands on your desk, time is of the essence. Take action within 24–48 hours to establish procedures and ensure everything stays on track.
Notify All Parties
The moment you receive written notice from the Government Accountability Office (GAO) about a protest, notify all relevant stakeholders without delay. If the contract has already been awarded, inform the awardee immediately. For situations where no award has been made, notify all offerors who still have a reasonable chance of winning the contract. If the protest occurs at the agency level and the award is on hold pending resolution, let those offerors with eligible proposals know about the situation.
Keep your notifications straightforward and factual. Be sure to instruct recipients to copy GAO and any other involved parties in their communications. (Source:)
Stop Contract Activities
Put all contract award or performance activities on hold until the protest is resolved. The only exception? If your agency determines there are urgent and compelling circumstances that require moving forward. In such cases, you’ll need to back up the decision with written findings detailing the urgency, the risks of delay, and why continuing is in the government’s best interest.
If you decide to proceed despite the protest, provide written notice of your decision to the protester and all other interested parties. For GAO protests, make sure GAO is informed before authorizing further actions. Keep comprehensive documentation of all decisions and steps taken to ensure a clear record for follow-up. (Source:)
Share Protest Documents
Once activities are paused, distribute all relevant protest documents as quickly as possible. Share these materials with the awardee (if applicable) or any offerors still in the running, making sure to redact any confidential or proprietary information as needed.
Prompt sharing of documents helps everyone prepare their responses efficiently. Continue to share updates or additional submissions as they come in to maintain transparency and fairness throughout the review process. (Source:)
Documentation and Record Keeping Checklist
Thorough documentation is the backbone of compliance and ensures every step of the bid protest process is supported. When a GAO protest notice arrives, it’s crucial to immediately gather all records that justify the agency’s actions.
Key Documents to Collect
For your protest file, make sure to include the following:
- The original protest.
- The offer submitted by the protester.
- The offer being considered for the award or under protest.
- All relevant evaluation records demonstrating adherence to the criteria outlined in the solicitation.
Additionally, include the complete solicitation, focusing on key specifications tied to the protest, and the abstract of offers or sections summarizing each offeror’s proposal.
When preparing your GAO report, ensure it contains:
- A signed statement of relevant facts, including your best estimate of the contract value, findings, actions taken, and recommendations.
- A memorandum of law.
- A list of all parties receiving the documents.
If the agency decides to proceed with awarding the contract or continuing performance despite the protest, include the written findings or other required documentation supporting that decision.
For agency-level protests, confirm that the protester’s submission includes:
- Full contact information.
- The solicitation or contract number.
- A detailed statement of legal and factual grounds.
- Copies of relevant documents.
- A request for a ruling and a statement of the relief sought.
- Evidence proving their status as an interested party.
Once all necessary documents are compiled, focus on organizing and securely storing them.
Organizing and Storing Records
To maintain order and accessibility, establish a systematic approach to organizing your records. A chronological filing system works well, tracking the entire procurement process – from solicitation and proposal submissions to evaluation activities, award decisions, and the protest itself. Use a master index to list each document with page numbers and brief descriptions.
Here’s a suggested method:
- Divide documents into folders by category (e.g., solicitation materials, proposals, evaluation records, award documentation, and protest correspondence).
- Arrange items by date within each folder.
- Redact sensitive information in compliance with 5 U.S.C. 552 before sharing.
For digital files, store them in a centralized location with backups. Use clear naming conventions, such as "2025-09-15_Evaluation_Summary", to make retrieval easy. Maintain detailed logs of who accesses the protest file and when, and track document distributions to ensure consistent and accurate information sharing.
Communication and Coordination During Protests
Once records are secured and organized, keeping communication lines open and clear is essential to navigating a protest effectively. Strong communication ensures your team can respond promptly and appropriately during the process.
Consult Your Legal Advisor
The moment a protest notice arrives, reach out to your legal counsel. Their expertise is crucial for handling litigation or protest-related issues. Before approving any suggested cost awards, ensure you’ve sought their advice. This step lays the groundwork for all subsequent communication and decisions throughout the protest.
After the Protest: Next Steps and Improvements
Once a bid protest wraps up, the focus shifts to addressing any issues and getting procurement processes back on track. This phase relies heavily on clear communication and thorough documentation to ensure every step is handled properly.
Taking Required Corrective Actions
If the Government Accountability Office (GAO) sides with the protestor, they’ll mandate corrective actions to fix any violations of procurement laws. It’s crucial to inform the GAO about your planned compliance steps. These actions might include re-evaluating proposals, revisiting the award decision, or making changes to the solicitation.
Conclusion
The steps outlined above provide a clear roadmap for effectively managing bid protests. Handling these situations requires meticulous documentation, transparent communication, and the right expertise. Following these practices can simplify the process and help achieve a smoother resolution.
From the moment a protest is filed, it’s essential to maintain thorough records – this includes solicitation documents, evaluation materials, and all related communications. Open and consistent communication with legal counsel, procurement teams, and agency leadership is equally important to ensure everyone is aligned and to minimize errors.
When dealing with complex protest issues, expert legal advice is indispensable. Contracting officers are required to consult legal counsel for all protests, whether they’re filed at the agency level, with the GAO, or at the Court of Federal Claims. In one notable case, expert legal guidance led to a reversed decision at the Court of Federal Claims, showcasing the importance of specialized support.
For businesses managing GSA Schedule contracts, having the right assistance throughout the procurement process is even more critical. GSA Focus offers tailored services to help small businesses secure and manage GSA Schedule Contracts. Their expertise in document preparation, compliance, and negotiation can reduce the likelihood of protest situations altogether. By following these structured procedures, contracting officers can better manage risks, ensure compliance, and strengthen their overall approach to bid protests.
FAQs
What are the main reasons for bid protests, and how can contracting officers minimize the risk of disputes?
Bid protests typically stem from problems such as inconsistent technical evaluations, mistakes in selection decisions, or errors in cost and price assessments. To reduce the chances of these disputes, contracting officers should prioritize clear communication, fair treatment, and detailed documentation throughout the procurement process.
Sticking closely to the evaluation criteria, following established protocols, and ensuring equal treatment of all bidders can go a long way in avoiding conflicts. Additionally, maintaining open lines of communication with offerors and keeping thorough records helps prevent confusion and ensures compliance with the rules.
What steps should contracting officers take immediately after a bid protest is filed?
When a bid protest is filed, contracting officers need to move quickly to address the situation while ensuring the procurement process remains fair and transparent. The first priority is to halt contract performance – this usually happens within the first 24 hours. This temporary pause prevents any further actions that could complicate the review process.
After that, it’s important to thoroughly review the protest’s details, officially document its receipt, and notify all key parties, including legal advisors and agency officials. Timing is critical here, especially with deadlines like the 10-day limit for protests submitted after award notifications. Following these steps helps manage the protest effectively and reduces potential risks to the procurement process.
What legal factors should contracting officers consider during a bid protest, and how can legal advisors help?
When handling a bid protest, contracting officers in the U.S. need to strictly follow legal protocols. This includes meeting all deadlines, keeping detailed records, and adhering to the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) rules that govern protests and disputes. These measures are essential for ensuring the process remains fair and compliant.
Legal advisors are indispensable in this process. They bring expertise in pinpointing valid protest issues, ensuring all procedures are correctly followed, and representing agencies if the situation escalates to formal hearings. Their support minimizes legal risks and helps contracting officers manage the complexities of bid protests with greater ease and precision.
Related Blog Posts
- Role of Contracting Officers in GSA Contracts
- GSA Post-Award Checklist for Contractors
- Checklist for Substantive GSA Contract Modifications
- Checklist for GSA Construction Contract Compliance
